Hot takes
i just know im going to get downvoted so bad but is it just me or ineffa/lauma > columbina?
I mean… if you have flins, ineffa worth more than columbina, if you have nefer, lauma worth more than columbina. If you want to play main dps columbina, you need BOTH ineffa and lauma. If you want to play lunar-charged wheelchair, you need ineffa to do shit ton of damage. If you want you play any bloom/lunar bloom wheelchair, well you guessed the answer, lauma is needed. The ONLY winner here is lunar-crystallize, even so only zibai can fully utilize it AND EVEN THAT, c6 illuga worth more than columbina.
I mean… if you have flins, ineffa worth more than columbina, if you have nefer, lauma worth more than columbina. If you want to play main dps columbina, you need BOTH ineffa and lauma. If you want to play lunar-charged wheelchair, you need ineffa to do shit ton of damage. If you want you play any bloom/lunar bloom wheelchair, well you guessed the answer, lauma is needed. The ONLY winner here is lunar-crystallize, even so only zibai can fully utilize it AND EVEN THAT, c6 illuga worth more than columbina.
Commentaires
Then Aino C6 can be better
It looks like Hoyo chose to make Columbina enhance the other Nod Krai Characters instead of just being the best on her own. That might be fairly disappointing to some people, which is valid, but after how much they overturned Ineffa and Lauma I’m glad they didn’t keep doing that.
She seems like a nice complement to lunar teams, which is what a lot of people were expecting anyway due to who she is. I’m glad Flins and Nefer and Zibai are still strong without her. And with her they are the best, so her contribution to the team, while not on par with Ineffa and Lauma, is not negligible either.
Columbina's value comes from replacing Aino, who does 0 damage and has a circle-impact hydro application, with a character that has decent sub-dps and more practical buffs and application, even if she's still not the best *dedicated* sub-dps and buffer. It's fine if she does less damage than Ineffa because she's meant to run alongside, not replace her. But if you have to pick between the two, Columbina is not a priority, she never is actually in any archetype. Even Zibai benefits more from getting her own constellations (alongside Illuga ones) than from staying C0 and pulling C0 Columbina.
You do know Ineffa, Furina, Xilonen/Sucrose/Bennet insert DPS doesnt have another 5 star NK
Both Lauma ans Ineffa are not niche they are completely self contained units and very very powerful in a vacuum
Ineffas is the best hyperbloom char in the game, she does well in overvape, heck ive seen some meme superconduct and it cleared the abyss fine
Lauma is the best bloom, hyperbloom, burgeon support in the game
Both arent niche at all
But Ineffa/Lauma + Columbina is quite good and in a spot where you don’t necessarily need the respective lunar dps
Columbina is just the turbocharger adding to what is already existed.
If people dont want to adress the elephant in the room thats fine im just looking at it objectively.
Theres a reason why Bina is underwhelming as it pertains to MDPS potential without Lauma same if you pair Bina with Nefer and no Lauma. The damage distrubution gives Lauma something like a ludicrous 55% share on potential and only herself/Nefer/Bina can profit from it.
If anyone cares to look at Laumas C2 and Ineffas R1/C1/C2
Both literally are a full on team by itself with a fn wet tissue in Aino (C6 Aino btw has 80 EM plus 35% Lunar Bonus which is competitive or flat better than Binas buffs)
They both self enhance themselves with no one else and enhance others just in their base kit, gives em, sustains, does a fton of damage on or off field, Lauma is harder to build and Ineffa can perform longer or shorter rotations.
Fact is Bina is balanced around both. Honeslty if you doubled down on giving TTds on Ineffa and a couple tweaks she'll do more damage in Flins best team. Thats the reality
Lauma - C2 Nahida, Nilou C2, Mini Escoffier, Shenhe Cons
Ineffa - Xiangling on steroids with a fn shield without the bs energy requurements and no need for Bennett, and selfless application. Right now you put Ineffa in a Nuevillette team you cant really say its a Nuevillette team can you