How good would this weapon be on columbina?

In this case let's say she's being used in lunarbloom team, which weapons would be better than this?

Commentaires

VictoryUnlikely45222026-01-07 15:09

prototype amber is much better if you plan to craft one for her. or fav codex if you already have it depending on your ER stats

suv-am2026-01-07 15:16

I already have R5 pa on my neuvilette so I guess I could use it on her. I have fav codex too, which is better among the two?

VictoryUnlikely45222026-01-07 15:17

it will depend on your team comp, how many hydros/fav weapons are on team etc. try them both depending on enemy/combat. Edit: to clarify, Pamber in stygian will be bad since you start with zero energy and cant burst to activate weapon, so Fav is obv a better choice there

suv-am2026-01-07 15:19

A quick question about sth I'm not entirely certain. Did they say that columbina by herself can obtain the lvl 2 lunar team bonus(don't remember what it's called)

VictoryUnlikely45222026-01-07 15:22

she has a passive "when Columbina is in the party, the party's Moonsign will increase by 1 level."

suv-am2026-01-07 15:23

Coolcoolcool. Thanks

Medyanka2026-01-07 17:28

Isn't it the same passive all of lunar characters have? Aka, with columbina in the party it is +1, which is for the party with ONLY columbina just 1?

Jahoda also have a passive "when Jahoda is in the party, the party's Moonsign will increase by 1 level". She doesn't make auto ascendant gleam though.

VictoryUnlikely45222026-01-07 17:41

correct , that is the only part in Columbina's kit related to OP's question, that's why I replied as above

Medyanka2026-01-07 17:50

I'm sure that he misunderstood you, aka "all moon characters have innate moonsign, but columbina have an [additional] passive to grant +1 to moonsogn". It's not that unnatural as well, since columbina gives us that effect every week in selenic chronicles.

Since you didn't say "no", before mentioning her passives, it sounds like you agree, and then mention passive as an explanation.

suv-am2026-01-07 15:27

I was hoping to use her with nahida and whichever character of those elements that feels necessary. What if I use a dendro and an electro? Hylerbloom, lunarbloom, lunar charge all 3, how good would that be?

VictoryUnlikely45222026-01-07 16:04

meowtew (one of the TCs) published this for Columbina ER reqs. as you can see numbers vary a lot based on what you plan to do. also note these are based on beta numbers, hoyo can pull a last minute trick and change anything on release like they did with nefer's EM.

https://imgur.com/a/c8EabMr

suv-am2026-01-07 16:05

I'm not familiar with beta info. What exactly did they do with nefers em?

VictoryUnlikely45222026-01-07 16:08

after creator experience videos were published on youtube, hoyo reduced nefer's base EM by 100 on release. so a dirty trick

suv-am2026-01-07 16:18

Guess they really hate her seeing how they also did her dirty during the rerir fight. Like I remember people saying they no longer wanted to pull for her

DaSpood2026-01-07 15:10

Ok only if you plan to use her as a main-dps or don't have favonius. Favonius is going to be a better weapon overall.

suv-am2026-01-07 15:15

Ok. Cool

WootyMcWoot2026-01-07 15:12

She’s isn’t a lunar bloom carry and she scales on hp, so terrible.

Medyanka2026-01-07 17:38

Ok, i'll not even mention her charged attack, since it's optional. But what do you think her skill is doing? For what purpose "gravity accumulation" is in her kit?

P.S. Personally, i also think that this weapon isn't really good on her, but not because "she doesn't do lunar-bloom damage"

WootyMcWoot2026-01-07 18:18

I mean she’s not a lunar bloom carry, buffing only the bloom damage from her gravity interference isn’t a meaningful way to build a team. I thought it was pretty obvious.

Medyanka2026-01-07 18:40

Your wording was a problem. Every single person who will find it obvious would not ask such a question in the first place. For them, your entire comment was a gross misinformation.

It's especially important in case of nod-krai characters that have not-so-obvious distinctions like "lunar-bloom reactions" and "lunar-bloom talent damage". Did you not see how many reddit post was out there claiming that crab boss is bugged?

WootyMcWoot2026-01-07 18:49

It don’t matter

None of this matters

Totally-Average-User2026-01-07 15:12

I plan using Columbina on a Nilou team plus Lauma C1 and Nahida. Is it a better option than Fav? Given she'll be the main bloom driver

Medyanka2026-01-07 17:32

How are you going to survive with that team though? No healers in Nilou team, and especially with dedicated driver that you want on-field that have to do charged attacks? Bloom self-damage falling from 5% to 2% will not save you.

I can't exactly imagine it to work out, honestly.

Totally-Average-User2026-01-07 18:14

I have Lauma C1, still wondering if that's enough

Scratchy992026-01-07 18:36

It is, Lauma C1 heals fast and for a good amount as well.

I unfortunately skipped on Lauma C1 (I ran out of primogems anyway since I was trying to get Nilou C5 on the chronicle wish banner) thinking C1's healing was bait and Columbina would have some kind of sustain but it turns out she does not

I'm gonna try to see if Columbina on prototype Amber could keep my team alive, since I do want to use my C2 Nahida in my premium Nilou bloom team. If not, I'll just use Baizhu until Lauma gets a rerun.

_krays2026-01-07 15:23

Looks solid for a Lunar-Bloom team! I'd say it's decent for her, but if you're looking for max damage, something like the Widsith could work better for a burst comp

Medyanka2026-01-07 17:35

No way it would work out with widsith - 2 out of 3 widsith buffs going into nowhere.

Even prototype amber will get you a better results, even without mentioning that with widsith you would absolutely require ER sands.

SarukyDraico2026-01-07 16:19

Top tier if you're blooming, absolute ass if you're not blooming